Why is Maduro still in power in Venezuela?

July 1, 2019

After massive protests, high international pressure and a coup attempt, the regime of Nicolás Maduro is still holding onto power in Venezuela. How is this possible? Although a range of factors keep Maduro in power, the central explanation is that he is transforming Venezuela from a petro-state into a narco-state. Maduro’s state is fragile, but could endure for longer than is widely expected.

Our observations

  • Venezuela is going through one of the worst economic crises in modern history. The IMF estimates that inflation will reach 10 million (!) percent in 2019. Unemployment will hit the 50%-mark next year. Most importantly, there is barely anything left of the oil industry on which the economy is heavily dependent (more than 90% of exports). Although Venezuela has the largest oil reserves in the world (18% of global known reserves), there are now 15 countries that produce more oil than Venezuela. Production dropped from a high of 3.5 million barrels per day in the 1970s to merely 000 today. To make matters worse, only 30% of production generates cash flow because the rest is used to pay off debt to China and Cuba (around 300.000 barrels per day go to China).
  • Domestic pressure on Maduro’s regime has increased significantly in the past two years. More than 100 people have died in the last year as protests are ongoing. Opposition leader Juan Guaidó supported a failed coup attempt.
  • International pressure on Maduro’s regime is higher than ever. More than 50 countries, including the U.S. and nearly all Latin American countries, have supported Guaidó’s claim to the presidency. S. sanctions, going back more than a decade, have badly damaged the economy. The Trump administration has extended sanctions to target Venezuela’s financial institutions and pressured other countries to isolate Venezuela economically.
  • In May 2019, the U.S. officially accused Maduro and his regime of leading an international drug trade. The U.S. has long known that the Venezuelan regime is building a narco-state (i.e. a state that is heavily dependent on the drug trade to remain intact), but now it has officially implicated Maduro himself.
  • A recent CNN report showcases the “cocaine super-highway” between the U.S. and Venezuela. In the past few months, the drug trade has grown rapidly. In 2017, there were 128 flights carrying cocaine from Venezuela to Central America. In 2018, there were 224 flights and in 2019 so far, officials have seen as many as eight flights per day. An estimated 240 tons of cocaine were shipped from Colombia to Venezuela in 2018 (up a third from the year before). That amounts to $40 billion if sold on the U.S. streets (where the drugs are headed), which is a whopping 17% of Venezuela’s GDP.

Connecting the dots

Not too long ago, Venezuela was at the forefront of global development. Back in 1950, Venezuela ranked 4th globally in terms of GDP per capita. The country became a democracy in 1958 and when nearly all of Latin America was ruled by military dictators during the 1970s, Venezuela’s democracy survived. However, after the 1999 election of Hugo Chávez, Venezuela’s political and economic institutions decayed. For one thing, Chávez turned the state-owned energy giant Petróleos de Venezuela (PDVSA) into an instrument of patronage, which steadily destroyed the oil industry (long before the U.S. imposed sanctions). Nicolás Maduro was handpicked by Hugo Chávez and in many ways has continued on the same path.Venezuela is now plagued by a rapid drop in living standards, frequent street protests, crippling sanctions, international pressure and an alleged coup. This raises the question how Maduro is still holding onto power. Indeed, commentators have predicted for Maduro’s regime to collapse for a long time. However, their narrative is too strongly focused on oil and autocratic rule. In fact, the oil industry is nearly nonexistent by now, and the Venezuelan state does not have any strong centralized institutions (unlike North Korea for example, which shares many of the features of Venezuela’s crisis). So how is Maduro able to hold onto power?Maduro controls the key institutions of the Venezuelan state through patronage (loyalty created by financial aid). Despite media attention for military officers that are “rising up” against Maduro, his grip on the military is strong. Only about 1000 members have defected (from a total of 100.000-200.000) – and nearly all of them chose to seek refuge in foreign countries, rather than stay and fight alongside the opposition. Besides the official state military, Maduro also finances paramilitary groups (the “colectivos”, which also act as leverage against the state military). The most important reason for Maduro’s control of the military is that he is making them rich. He gave control of both PDVSA and the drug trade to the military. Maduro also controls the political system by stacking the Supreme Court with his loyalists. Indeed, patronage is key to Maduro’s control of the state.Through the legacy of Chávez, Maduro still has support among the working class. For decades, Venezuela’s slums, the “barrios”, have supported Chávez and Maduro. Although Chávez is widely recognized as a dictator, he was highly popular among working class people because he seized on the plight of the barrios (for example, the social program of Barrio Adentro built healthcare clinics in the slums). So instead of defending Maduro, the barrios are defending Chavismo, a political project that gives them a voice. They’re afraid of once again being forgotten when Maduro is removed from power. This explains why support for Juan Guaidó remains weak. Although Guaidó has made slow inroads into the barrios, he is fighting the powerful spirit of Chavismo. Popular support for Guaidó dwindled once he supported more U.S. sanctions to topple Maduro: it showed the working class that Guaidó represents another (neoliberal) figure that is likely to neglect the barrios (like Chávez’ predecessors).Venezuela has geopolitical allies that save Maduro from complete isolation due to the U.S.-led campaign. For decades, Cuba has supported the regimes of Chávez and Maduro with military and security assistance (in exchange for oil). Russia is also a key partner for Venezuela. For instance, Russian energy company Rosneft is helping PDVSA circumvent U.S. sanctions by purchasing Venezuelan oil at a discount. While China is open to working with any government in Venezuela (including Guaidó), it is also supporting Maduro’s regime. From 2007 to 2017, China provided loans of more than $60 billion to the Venezuelan government (also in exchange for oil).A central factor that connects all of the above is the drug trade. Venezuela’s commodity dependence is simply shifting from oil to drugs. It was Chávez who turned Venezuela into a petro-state: a state with weak political institutions that is highly dependent on oil. But since the oil industry has been steadily destroyed, Maduro was forced to shift from oil to something else. Drugs are now a lucrative trade for Maduro’s regime that is also much harder for the U.S. to fight. It is likely that without the drug trade, Maduro would have already lost power because he would not have been able to pay off the military. Building a narco-state also allows Maduro to keep control of the restless barrios and keep the oil flowing to Cuba and China. All in all, the centrality of the drug trade to Maduro’s hold on power shows how weak Venezuela’s state has actually become. By turning illicit trade into the backbone of his patronage, Maduro has made his regime very fragile. However, contrary to the prevailing narrative, if the drug trade keeps the cash flowing, Maduro could remain in power for much longer than expected.

Implications

  • The U.S. could remove Maduro from power, but that would require much more political energy from Washington, which is unlikely in the near future. To topple Maduro’s regime, the U.S. must stop the drug trade. But current U.S. policy will fail to do so. The U.S. Drug Enforcement Agency, which is active across Latin America, was kicked out of Venezuela by Chávez in 2005. Moreover, U.S. sanctions that are capable of stopping the flow of oil cannot impede the traffic of cocaine. Nothing short of military intervention will stop the drug trade, but the U.S. will not put boots on the ground in Venezuela. The only option is for the U.S. to use far more (military) resources to stop drugs from moving into other countries from Venezuela. However, since the Trump administration is more focused on China, Iran and the South China Sea, that is unlikely to happen in the near future.
  • Even severe economic crises do not necessarily bring down authoritarian regimes. A lesson that can be learned from Venezuela is that authoritarian regimes have a playbook for economic crises to keep themselves in power. When the government takes one or several groups to isolate them from the crisis (e.g. military, drug lords, government officials), and turns more repressive, an institutional regime emerges that is, albeit weak, strong enough to retain control of the state for some time. Similar strategies kept the regimes of Arab dictators and Latin American military regimes alive for long periods of time.

Series 'AI Metaphors'

×
1. The tool
Category: The object
Humans shape tools. We make them part of our body while we melt their essence with our intentions. They require some finesse to use but they never fool us or trick us. Humans use tools, tools never use humans. We are the masters determining their course, integrating them gracefully into the minutiae of our everyday lives. Immovable and unyielding, they remain reliant on our guidance, devoid of desire and intent, they remain exactly where we leave them, their functionality unchanging over time. We retain the ultimate authority, able to discard them at will or, in today's context, simply power them down. Though they may occasionally foster irritation, largely they stand steadfast, loyal allies in our daily toils. Thus we place our faith in tools, acknowledging that they are mere reflections of our own capabilities. In them, there is no entity to venerate or fault but ourselves, for they are but inert extensions of our own being, inanimate and steadfast, awaiting our command. (This paragraph was co-authored by a human.)
Read the article
×
2. The machine
Category: The object
Unlike a mere tool, the machine does not need the guidance of our hand, operating autonomously through its intricate network of gears and wheels. It achieves feats of motion that surpass the wildest human imaginations, harboring a power reminiscent of a cavalry of horses. Though it demands maintenance to replace broken parts and fix malfunctions, it mostly acts independently, allowing us to retreat and become mere observers to its diligent performance. We interact with it through buttons and handles, guiding its operations with minor adjustments and feedback as it works tirelessly. Embodying relentless purpose, laboring in a cycle of infinite repetition, the machine is a testament to human ingenuity manifested in metal and motion. (This paragraph was co-authored by a human.)
Read the article
×
3. The robot
Category: The object
There it stands, propelled by artificial limbs, boasting a torso, a pair of arms, and a lustrous metallic head. It approaches with a deliberate pace, the LED bulbs that mimic eyes fixating on me, inquiring gently if there lies any task within its capacity that it may undertake on my behalf. Whether to rid my living space of dust or to fetch me a chilled beverage, this never complaining attendant stands ready, devoid of grievances and ever-willing to assist. Its presence offers a reservoir of possibilities; a font of information to quell my curiosities, a silent companion in moments of solitude, embodying a spectrum of roles — confidant, servant, companion, and perhaps even a paramour. The modern robot, it seems, transcends categorizations, embracing a myriad of identities in its service to the contemporary individual. (This paragraph was co-authored by a human.)
Read the article
×
4. Intelligence
Category: The object
We sit together in a quiet interrogation room. My questions, varied and abundant, flow ceaselessly, weaving from abstract math problems to concrete realities of daily life, a labyrinthine inquiry designed to outsmart the ‘thing’ before me. Yet, with each probe, it responds with humanlike insight, echoing empathy and kindred spirit in its words. As the dialogue deepens, my approach softens, reverence replacing casual engagement as I ponder the appropriate pronoun for this ‘entity’ that seems to transcend its mechanical origin. It is then, in this delicate interplay of exchanging words, that an unprecedented connection takes root that stirs an intense doubt on my side, am I truly having a dia-logos? Do I encounter intelligence in front of me? (This paragraph was co-authored by a human.)
Read the article
×
5. The medium
Category: The object
When we cross a landscape by train and look outside, our gaze involuntarily sweeps across the scenery, unable to anchor on any fixed point. Our expression looks dull, and we might appear glassy-eyed, as if our eyes have lost their function. Time passes by. Then our attention diverts to the mobile in hand, and suddenly our eyes light up, energized by the visual cues of short videos, while our thumbs navigate us through the stream of content. The daze transforms, bringing a heady rush of excitement with every swipe, pulling us from a state of meditative trance to a state of eager consumption. But this flow is pierced by the sudden ring of a call, snapping us again to a different kind of focus. We plug in our earbuds, intermittently shutting our eyes, as we withdraw further from the immediate physical space, venturing into a digital auditory world. Moments pass in immersed conversation before we resurface, hanging up and rediscovering the room we've left behind. In this cycle of transitory focus, it is evident that the medium, indeed, is the message. (This paragraph was co-authored by a human.)
Read the article
×
6. The artisan
Category: The human
The razor-sharp knife rests effortlessly in one hand, while the other orchestrates with poised assurance, steering clear of the unforgiving edge. The chef moves with liquid grace, with fluid and swift movements the ingredients yield to his expertise. Each gesture flows into the next, guided by intuition honed through countless repetitions. He knows what is necessary, how the ingredients will respond to his hand and which path to follow, but the process is never exactly the same, no dish is ever truly identical. While his technique is impeccable, minute variation and the pursuit of perfection are always in play. Here, in the subtle play of steel and flesh, a master chef crafts not just a dish, but art. We're witnessing an artisan at work. (This paragraph was co-authored by a human.)
Read the article
×
7. The deficient animal
Category: The human
Once we became upright bipedal animals, humans found themselves exposed and therefore in a state of fundamental need and deficiency. However, with our hands now free and our eyes fixed on the horizon instead of the ground, we gradually evolved into handy creatures with foresight. Since then, human beings have invented roofs to keep them dry, fire to prepare their meals and weapons to eliminate their enemies. This genesis of man does not only tell us about the never-ending struggle for protection and survival, but more fundamentally about our nature as technical beings, that we are artificial by nature. From the early cave drawings, all the way to the typewriter, touchscreens, and algorithmic autocorrections, technics was there, and is here, to support us in our wondering and reasoning. Everything we see and everywhere we live is co-invented by technics, including ourselves. (This paragraph was co-authored by a human.)
Read the article
×
8. The enhanced human
Category: The human
In a lab reminiscent of Apple HQ, a figure lies down, receiving his most recent cognitive updates. He wears a sleek transparent exoskeleton, blending the dark look of Bat Man with the metallic of Iron Man. Implemented in his head, we find a brain-computer interface, enhancing his cognitive abilities. His decision making, once burdened by the human deficiency we used to call hesitation or deliberation, now takes only fractions of seconds. Negative emotions no longer fog his mind; selective neurotransmitters enhance only the positive, fostering beneficial social connections. His vision, augmented to perceive the unseen electromechanical patterns and waves hidden from conventional sight, paints a deeper picture of the world. Garbed in a suit endowed with physical augmentations, he moves with strength and agility that eclipse human norms. Nano implants prolong the inevitable process of aging, a buffer against time's relentless march to entropy. And then, as a penultimate hedge against the finite, the cryo-cabin awaits, a sanctuary to preserve his corporal frame while bequeathing his consciousness to the digital immortality of coded existence. (This paragraph was co-authored by a human.)
Read the article
×
9. The cyborg
Category: The human
A skin so soft and pure, veins pulsing with liquid electricity. This fusion of flesh and machinery, melds easily into the urban sprawl and daily life of future societies. Something otherworldly yet so comfortingly familiar, it embodies both pools of deep historical knowledge and the yet-to-be. It defies categorization, its existence unraveling established narratives. For some, its hybrid nature is a perplexing anomaly; for others, this is what we see when we look into the mirror. This is the era of the cyborg. (This paragraph was co-authored by a human.)
Read the article

About the author(s)

At sister company Dasym, Alexander has been assigned a variety of tasks, for his interests transcend branches of knowledge as well as geographical boundaries. In brief, he writes policy papers, interprets and elucidates global developments, and conducts thematic investment research. His academic background spans public administration, history of international relations, and philosophy, having published dissertations on smart cities, Ethiopian sovereignty and independence, and Chinese philosophy towards technology. Integral to his responsibilities, Alexander wades through the latest literature on geopolitics, technology, financial markets and cultural anthropology.

You may also like